Hyperintensionality, Opacity, Deep StructureNicholas K. Jones (University of Oxford)
Plesso D'Azeglio, Aula D
Strada Massimo D’Azeglio 85
Parma
Italy
Organisers:
Topic areas
Details
Abstract
Tension has arisen in contemporary metaphysics. On the one hand, the “hyperintensional revolution” ongoing since the turn of the century has seen increasingly widespread uptake of hyperintensional tools in pure metaphysics and increasingly also elsewhere; for example, essence, real definition, determination, ground, and fundamentality. These tools appear to require fine-grained distinctions between necessarily equivalent properties, relations, and propositions (PRPs). On the other hand, it has become clear that an adequate fine-grained theory of PRPs is hard to find. I will explore a new resolution of this tension, on which the fine-grained, hyperintensional language of metaphysics does not require a correspondingly fine-grained metaphysics of PRPs. The key theoretical tool is a distinction between two very different kinds of hyperintensionality: hyperintensional distinctions and hyperintensional opacity. I will explore the hypothesis that hyperintensional metaphysical tools are opaque, resulting in a mismatch between the structures of language and reality. I also sketch a precise implementation of this hypothesis for the special case of fundamentality.
Registration
No
Who is attending?
1 person is attending:
Will you attend this event?