Patrick Duerr - Principled inquiry: a functionalist account of principles in physics (and beyond)Patrick Duerr
1117 Cathedral of Learning - 11th Floor
University of Pittsburgh, 4200 Fifth Avenue
Pittsburgh 15260
United States
This event is available both online and in-person
Organisers:
Details
The Center for Philosophy of Science at the University of Pittsburgh invites you to join us for our Lunch Time Talk. Attend in person at 1117 Cathedral of Learning or visit our live stream on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrRp47ZMXD7NXO3a9Gyh2sg.
Lunch Time Talk: Patrick Duerr
Tuesday, February 2nd @ 12:00 pm - 1:30 pm EST
Title: Principled inquiry: a functionalist account of principles in physics (and beyond)
Abstract:
Principles – such as conservation laws for energy or momentum, the Principle of Least Action, or the Copernican Principle – are indispensable and ubiquitous in physical practice. Yet they appear to fit uneasily into the standard epistemological categories of philosophy of science, preoccupied as they are with truth or evidence for propositions. Taking inspiration from Cassirer, Einstein and David Stump, I shall present and defend an account of principles in terms of their epistemic or heuristic role in the architecture or construction of models and theories: as building blocks for physical theorising that serve (or are supposed to serve) a particular function. The functionalist perspective suggests a natural taxonomy, dividing principles into two principal classes: regulative ones (which order and organise inquiry at a relatively abstract level), and more concrete, constitutive ones (which delimit physical possibilities that the researcher countenances). The account has both descriptive and normative dimensions. Principles are assessed pluralistically and pragmatically with respect to their adequacy for these purposes – on the strength of the reasons, diverse in kind, highly context-sensitive and historically variable, that scientists have for deeming the principles apt for the intended or actual functions. I shall argue that the proposed account has three key virtues: (i) it seems to do justice to the centrality of principles in scientific practice, especially research on the cusp of the unknown; (ii) it is useful as a diagnostic tool for scientific crises, and offers (appropriately) modest, but nonetheless nontrivial advice about ways forward; (iii) it points to a 'dynamics of scientific reason' that illuminates the rationality of the history of science, without lapsing into Friedman's anti-naturalism or Lakatosian pseudo-historical reconstructions. Provocatively, I shall conclude by mooting principles, construed functionally, as the pragmatic and pluralist heirs to the Kantian a priori – as contemporary solutions to the Kantian problematic, as it poses itself for modern physics.
The talk expands on an analysis of principles in the context of the Dark Matter problem, co-authored with James Read (Oxford): https://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/30881/.
Key words: principles, neo-Kantianism, progress, heuristics and theory development, rationality
This talk will be available online:
Zoom: TBA
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrRp47ZMXD7NXO3a9Gyh2sg
Registration
No
Who is attending?
No one has said they will attend yet.
Will you attend this event?