The Ideal of Recognition in Contemporary Normative Theory

September 7, 2021 - September 10, 2021
Manchester Centre for Political Theory, University of Manchester

Manchester
United Kingdom

View the Call For Papers

Organisers:

University of California, Berkeley

Topic areas

Talks at this conference

Add a talk

Details

The Ideal of Recognition in Contemporary Normative Theory

MANCEPT Workshops 2021 (online)

Convener: Nick French (University of California, Berkeley)

Submission deadline: May 16, 2021

Recognition and closely related notions have played prominent roles in recent moral, political, and social theory. It is central to Louis Althusser’s account of ideology and accounts of ideology inspired by it, which understand recognition to be a central mechanism by which dominant classes secure the cooperation and consent of the dominated. Recognition is also crucial to the critical theory of Axel Honneth, who sees relations of mutual recognition as the ultimate goal of emancipatory social struggles and as an immanent ideal with which to criticize existing social practices. T.M. Scanlon’s influential contractualist theory of morality uses the notion of mutual recognition to explain our reasons for caring about our moral obligations to fellow persons. Philosophers such as Stephen Darwall and R. Jay Wallace have appealed to notions of interpersonal respect and recognition to illuminate practices of moral accountability (e.g., blame and apology) and authority relations. And of course, the notion of recognition has been central to attempts to theorize social movements associated with multiculturalism and identity politics.

These thinkers and others have invoked different conceptions of recognition for a variety of explanatory purposes. This workshop aims to bring together theorists working on topics related to the notion of recognition from diverse normative disciplines and theoretical perspectives, from both “analytic” and “Continental” backgrounds, with the hope of generating fruitful dialogue across different approaches. We are interested in exploring questions such as the following:

  • What is the relationship between various conceptions of recognition? For example, what is the relationship between value-neutral conceptions of recognition (like Althusser’s) and conceptions of recognition as a positive value (such as Honneth’s or Scanlon’s)?

  • Can a single notion of recognition play multiple theoretical roles—for instance, articulating both the driving force of emancipatory social struggles and an ideal of personal morality?

  • Can recognition provide an overarching framework for addressing questions of social justice, or must it be supplemented by other concepts (e.g., that of distributive justice)?

  • What is the relationship between the recently much discussed phenomenon of “bipolar obligations” and mutual recognition? Between mutual recognition and Darwall’s “second-personal reasons”?

  • Most theorists of recognition see a connection between that notion and that of autonomy. How should we understand the relationship of different conceptions of recognition to autonomy of various kinds (personal, moral, political)?

  • How might conceptual or empirical work in moral psychology inform our thinking about recognition?

If you wish to present a paper at the workshop, please submit a 300-500 word abstract of your paper, prepared for blind review, by Sunday, May 16, 2021. Email all abstracts and inquiries to workshop convener Nick French (nick.french@berkeley.edu). Authors of accepted abstracts will be notified within two weeks. We aim to provide each speaker 15-20 minutes to present and then 25-30 minutes for Q&A. 

*Information on MANCEPT: Registration for the conference opens in May. All participants must register to attend.

This year’s fees are:
Academics: £45
Graduate students, retirees, and unaffiliated attendees: £20
Non-speaker/non-presenting attendees: £15

MANCEPT offers fee-waiver bursaries to attend the conference (available for current graduate students only), and the application deadline for a bursary is June 15, 2021. To give presenters time to apply for a bursary, authors will be notified by June 8, 2021.

For more information, please visit MANCEPT’s website:
https://sites.manchester.ac.uk/mancept/mancept-workshops/ *

Supporting material

Add supporting material (slides, programs, etc.)

Reminders

Registration

No

Who is attending?

No one has said they will attend yet.

Will you attend this event?


Let us know so we can notify you of any change of plan.