About Time: the de nunc and the de se
13-15 Beech Grove Terrace
- The Mind Association; The Thought Trust
Talks at this conferenceAdd a talk
Event-details: Monday the 10th and Tuesday the 11th of June 2019, University of Leeds
Conference Organisers: Léa Salje (Leeds), l.c.salje [at] leeds.ac.uk, and Daniel Morgan (York), d.morgan [at] york.ac.uk
- Marie Guillot (Essex)
- Robin Le Poidevin (Leeds)
- Daniel Morgan (York)
- Simon Prosser (St-Andrews)
- Komarine Romdenh-Romluc (Sheffield)
- Matthew Soteriou (KCL)
Submission: There are two additional slots for speakers. If you are interested in speaking, please submit a 750-1000 word abstract prepared for blind review to d.morgan[at]york.ac.uk by noon on January 31 2019. Applicants will be contacted within two weeks of the deadline.
We welcome submissions from everyone, and especially encourage submissions from underrepresented groups in philosophy. We welcome participation from PhD students and early-career researchers.
Talk format: Speakers will be invited to give a 50-minute talk, followed by a 30-minute general discussion.
Accommodation and travel: the conference can pay for two nights accommodation for speakers, and for travel expenses from within the U.K.
Registration: the conference is open to everybody and free to attend.
Discussion of indexical thought in contemporary philosophy of mind is dominated by de se thought. The appeal is plausibly that of a privileged deviant: de se thought doesn’t seem to behave like other kinds of singular thought, and its misbehaviour apparently earns it a highly privileged and basic role in our cognitive economies. It is sometimes observed — though typically as something of an afterthought — that de nunc thought displays some analogous behavioural features, and that it correspondingly occupies an analogue of some aspects of the privileged cognitive role associated with de se thought. For instance, like de se thought, it is plausible that all de nunc thoughts are guaranteed against netting an unintended object or no object at all, and that some de nunc thoughts are IEM. And arguably, de se and de nunc thought play roughly symmetrical roles in psychological explanations of action. But the particulars are often left gestural, with readers left to fill in the details from the case of de se thought.
By prioritising de se thought as the central platform for discussion of indexical thought in general, we risk systematically under-recognising some of the most important and unusual features of de nunc thought. The aim of this conference is to consider ways in which we might reframe discussion of de nunc thought on its own terms. We discuss important epistemic goods had by de nunc states that are lacking from de se states,that have risked falling under the radar. For example, temporal indexical thought is comparatively much less tolerant of substantive misconceptions of its object than I-thought is, and the range of judgments that are IEM relative to a de nunc concept is vastly greater than those IEM relative to a de se concept. Our discussion brings a somewhat revisionary idea in its train: that a properly worked out philosophy of mind for indexical temporal thought will show de nunc thought to play a more fundamental role in our cognitive economies than the historically privileged de se thought.
Questions to be discussed might include (but are not limited to):
- How should we think about the interaction between the metaphysics of time and the conceptual role of temporal thought?
- What is the role of memory and perception in temporal thought?
- What have different philosophical traditions to say about temporal thought?
- Are there epistemic goods had by de nunc thought not shared by de se thought?
- Does the reference of de se thought work differently from the reference of de nunc thought?
With thanks to: The Mind Association. The Thought Trust.
Please get in touch with the organisers if you have any questions.
Who is attending?
No one has said they will attend yet.
Will you attend this event?